GMO Testing Modality Comparison: On-Site QuickCombs and PCR Testing

photo of EnviroLogix’ 10-up GMO Corn
QuickComb for QuickScan in solution cup with carboard holder

EnviroLogix’ 10-up GMO Corn
QuickComb for QuickScan

One of the most frequent questions we get asked about our on-site GMO test for corn is why testing in corn requires a 10-up “comb” on inbound testing, but only a 4-assay PCR panel lab test to meet most common compliance standards.

EnviroLogix’ immunoassays detect GMO proteins in grain, whereas our PCR detects the GMO DNA. The table below shows the relationship between our corn comb (10 unique GMO Lateral Flow Device [LFD] strips connected with a bridge for easy handling) and the most commonly tested PCR panel.

Crop science laboratories are now routinely commercializing new traits on a regular basis. To keep your non-GMO operation compliant, EnviroLogix continually updates this table on our website, where you can also find a similar table for soy traits.

Table 1. Immunoassay GMO Trait Proteins and PCR GMO DNA Sequences

QuickScan
10-up Comb
Cry1 CP4 EPSPS Cry3 Cry1F PAT/pat Cry34 Cry2 mCry3A VIP eCry3.1Ab
PCR
Standard Panel
CaMV 35s MIR604 MIR162 GA21
photo showing PCR DNA test

PCR DNA Test

If you’re interested in why this works for GMO testing, the answer gets very technical very quickly. The root comes down the biological basis of GMOs. Most modifications add DNA from one organism to a plant’s genome to allow that plant to express a new protein that creates a trait of interest.

For a plant to make a new protein, the added DNA includes both the sequence for the protein, as well as regulatory element sequence that “tells” the plant to turn that protein production on. Those regulatory sequences are often reused in many different GMO traits, which means that some GMOs might create different proteins but they have a common DNA sequence. The most common regulatory sequence used in GMOs and tested by PCR is CaMV 35s, which is a short piece of DNA from cauliflower mosaic virus.

PCR testing is complex and costly. To minimize the amount of testing needed, a CaMV 35s assay is commonly used to detect DNA from many different GMO traits at the same time. Conversely, these sequences cannot be tested by a common immunoassay strip; they are designed for quick screening and trait differentiation, which is why we continue to add more LFD strips to the comb over time.

Figure 1. Relationship between GMO Trait DNA and Expressed GMO Trait Protein
Diagram showing the relationship between GMO traits and GMO proteins from corn

Increased Demand Drives New GMO Testing Technology

A recent article in The Organic & Non-GMO Report described the increased interest in non-GMO (genetically modified organism) labeling, which is driving the increased demand for faster, cheaper and more accurate GMO testing technology.

More food companies are getting their products verified as GMO-free to meet consumer demand and the new national GMO labeling law. Non-GMO verification is based on testing. This testing ensures that the GMO content in food ingredients is below the acceptable threshold, as defined by non-GMO verification programs like the Non-GMO Project and NSF’s True North Program. The most common threshold of acceptance for GMO content is 0.9%, which is consistent with the threshold for GMO labeling in Europe, although the Non-GMO project does have different thresholds for seed and animal feed.

Current GMO Testing Technology

There are two widely-used methods for GMO detection. Lateral flow devices, or LFDs, detect proteins on a test strip and are most often used on-site due to their ease of use and rapid results. In contrast, PCR is performed in a laboratory. It detects the DNA of a genetically modified trait, and is the current “gold standard” test method because of its sensitivity and precision and ability to detect GMOs in processed foods. However, PCR testing does have its drawbacks. It can take up to three days and is costly, especially compared to LFD testing.

Currently, many companies use both testing methods. LFD strips are often used to screen incoming commodities for GMOs and then PCR testing is used to quantify the amount of GM presence. According to Jamie Welch, a scientist at EnviroLogix, “the two systems work well in conjunction [but] both have benefits and drawbacks.”

New GMO Testing Technology

There are new testing technologies on the horizon. With more consumers demanding to know what is in their food, and GMO labeling laws being passed, more food manufacturers are taking a closer look at their suppliers and asking for assurance that their materials are non-GMO compliant. It is critical that GMO testing be easy, affordable and fast to keep pace with the needs of the global  food supply chain.

EnviroLogix developed a rapid molecular-based testing platform called DNAble. It is similar to PCR, but faster and much less expensive. It is so easy to use that testing can be performed on-site in a matter of minutes.

“It does what PCR does but with a crude sample and in less than 10 minutes,” says Dean Layton, a Senior VP at EnviroLogix, “anyone that has a basic lab setup but needs real time point-of-need answers could benefit from it.”

 

 

Photo credit: The Organic & Non-GMO Report

Pack Your Plaid and Join Us at MOSES

Visit us at MOSES in booth #140 to learn about our rapid, user-friendly solutions for detecting GMOs and mycotoxins. While you’re there, enter to win a $100 LL Bean gift card!

Our simple immunoassay solutions are:

  • Easy to use
  • Flexible
  • Precise

Our revolutionary molecular technology can detect the DNA of genetically modified organisms, using patented chemistry that is:

  • Quick
  • Sensitive
  • Accurate

Stop by to talk with Kyle and Lee about your specific testing challenges. We have the expertise you need in a strategic partner and the solutions you can trust for success.

Scientist Jamie Welch to Present at the Organic & Non-GMO Forum

According to event organizers, The Organic & Non-GMO Forum is a unique one-day event that brings together stakeholders from across the organic and non-GMO value chain to address the growing opportunities and the significant supply chain challenges that still remain. The event features:

  • Interactive presentations and panel discussions with industry experts
  • Crucial information, strategies and tools to engage in the sector
  • An opportunity to meet companies within in growing sector
  • The only event that connects the entire oilseed and grains supply chain to address the critical challenges that lie ahead

Scientist Jamie Welch, Supervisor of Technical Support at EnviroLogix, will present on the current science of GMO testing protocols from 9:55 – 10:20 am on September 30.

If you’re planning to attend, please be our guest and save 10% off of your registration fee by using the discount code ONG-SK15.

Leave time on your agenda to attend Jamie’s presentation on GMO testing science, and visit our table at the expo for information and GMO testing demos. If you are thinking about entering the non-GMO market, or if you have questions about your existing program,  talk with our friendly, knowledgeable experts about your unique challenges. We can help develop a solution for your needs.

 

Test Your Exports for GMOs With Confidence

EnviroLogix, the industry leader in GMO detection, is looking forward to seeing you at the US SOY Global Trade Exchange/Midwest Specialty Grains Conference & Trade Show. According to Feed & Grain magazine, the conference has reached a new record for attendance, so it will be a phenomenal event!

The non-GMO market is expanding, both in the U.S. and abroad, so don’t get left behind! GMO testing is fast, simple and affordable. EnviroLogix is the only company offering rapid detection technology options for all GMO traits, and our industry experts can help develop a solution for your needs.

Visit our friendly, knowledgeable staff at booth # 205 during the trade show to talk about your unique challenges, and leave some time in your schedule for one of our live demos.

product-image

 

DNAble GMO Soybean Screen

Thursday, 9/10 @ 12:45 pm and Friday, 9/11 @ 8:15 am

The future of testing is here! We made rapid DNA detection simple and affordable.
Watch how easy it is to detect multiple GMO traits in minutes.
 

QuickScan-TechQuickScan GMO Test Strips

Thursday, 9/10 @ 1:30 pm and Friday, 9/11 @ 1:00 pm

Observe the fast, reliable results achieved with this trusted technique.

Save your data, print reports and detect mycotoxins on the same system!

midwest shippers